My Insurance Store
Reviews read through Mar 5, 2026 · Scored Aug 28, 2026 · 99 reviews read
Listing details verified 6 days ago.
My Insurance Store stands out for its friendly and responsive service, particularly from agents like Melissa and Dustin, according to many reviewers. The agency is noted for competitive pricing, often helping customers secure better rates than they found elsewhere. However, there are complaints regarding service inconsistencies and errors in paperwork that can complicate the customer experience.
What reviewers consistently mention
Several reviewers note that Melissa provides friendly and quick service, making the process smooth and efficient for obtaining insurance policies.
Multiple customers mention that My Insurance Store offers competitive rates, with several experiences highlighting significant savings on policies compared to other companies.
Watch out for
Several reviewers report issues with customer service, citing rudeness and unresponsiveness when attempting to reach the agency by phone.
How the reviews break down
4.9★ average from 204 Google reviews
- 5★191 94%
- 4★7 3%
- 3★3 1%
- 2★0 0%
- 1★3 1%
Low ratings are rare here — 1% of reviews are one or two stars.
Services offered by My Insurance Store
- Insurance Agency
The agency provides expert assistance in securing insurance policies tailored to individual needs, navigating various options and clarifying any questions.
- Home Insurance Agency
This agency specializes in offering home insurance policies designed to protect residences and personal property from potential risks.
- Insurance Broker
As a broker, the agency connects clients with multiple insurance carriers to find the most suitable coverage options for their requirements.
- Life Insurance Agency
The life insurance service focuses on helping clients select appropriate life insurance policies to ensure financial protection for loved ones.
- Online appointments
- On-site service available
- Wheelchair accessible parking
Cities
Where My Insurance Store ranks
Request a quote from My Insurance Store
Not heard back within two business days? Tell us and we will chase it, and point you at other insurance agencys we score well.
Own this business?
Claim the listing to correct your details and respond to what reviewers raised. Claiming cannot change your score or your position.
Claim this listingMore local Insurance Agencies in Dallas-Fort Worth
View All- 69.6Freeway Insurance4.5★ (280)
Insurance Agency · Carrollton
Getting quotes from friendly staff, personalized service
- 74.1Acer Auto Insurance4.8★ (76)
Insurance Agency · Lewisville
Friendly service, quick responses to inquiries
- 61.4William Edwards: Allstate Insurance5.0★ (18)
Insurance Agency · Rockwall
William Edwards: Allstate Insurance offers a range of insurance services, including property, casualty, business, and life insurance. The agency is staffed by five experienced professionals with over 50 years of combined industry knowledge, serving more than 3,000 households in Texas.